Cars Are Going Electric. What Happens to the Used Batteries?

3 weeks ago 25

This summer, Dirk Spiers, a tall, rumpled Dutchman-turned-Oklahoman, got a heads-up from General Motors astir much problems with the Chevrolet Bolt. Over the erstwhile year, the car exemplary that had erstwhile been celebrated arsenic GM’s grand triumph implicit Tesla—the United States’ archetypal genuinely mass-market electric vehicle—had begun to look much similar a slow-motion disaster. Bolts were being recalled due to the fact that of a bid of rare but destructive fires sparked erstwhile drivers near their cars charging overnight. GM had traced the occupation to flaws successful the lithium-ion artillery cells manufactured by South Korea’s LG Chem.

Now the automaker was expanding the callback to each 141,000 Bolts sold worldwide since 2017. Fixing them would beryllium a monolithic operation. Unlike the toaster-oven-sized lead-acid batteries wrong astir gas-powered vehicles, the lithium-ion artillery battalion wrong the Bolt runs the afloat wheelbase of the car and weighs 960 pounds. It contains hundreds of artillery cells that are delicate and finicky. When taken isolated for repairs, they tin beryllium dangerous, and incorrect handling tin pb to noxious fumes and fires.

Spiers was a earthy idiosyncratic to telephone for help. His narration with GM had begun 11 years earlier, erstwhile helium buttonholed the company’s caput of improvement for an earlier electrical vehicle, the Volt, astir GM’s program for the batteries erstwhile they broke oregon died. It turned retired GM didn’t truly person one. Spiers turned that opening into a concern that present handles the logistics of dormant and dying EV batteries from each large carmaker that sells successful the US, but Tesla. Spiers New Technologies takes flawed batteries and transports, tests, and—when possible—disassembles, fixes, and refurbishes them. “We get our hands dirty,” Spiers says.

When batteries can’t beryllium fixed oregon reused, the institution recycles immoderate astatine its onsite facility. It besides stores batteries. Lots of them. SNT’s main warehouse successful Oklahoma City holds hundreds of electrical car batteries, stacked connected shelves that jut 30 feet into the air. With the Bolt recall, GM volition nonstop SNT galore more.

Those batteries, and millions much similar them that volition yet travel disconnected the road, are a situation for the world’s electrified future. Automakers are pouring billions into electrification with the committedness that this procreation of cars volition beryllium cleaner than their gas-powered predecessors. By the extremity of the decade, the International Energy Agency estimates determination volition beryllium betwixt 148 cardinal and 230 cardinal battery-powered vehicles connected the roadworthy worldwide, accounting for up to 12 percent of the planetary automotive fleet.

The past happening anyone wants is for those batteries to go waste. Lithium-ion batteries, similar different electronics, are toxic, and tin origin destructive fires that dispersed quickly—a information that runs particularly precocious erstwhile they are stored together. A recent EPA report recovered that lithium-ion batteries caused astatine slightest 65 fires astatine municipal discarded facilities past year, though astir were ignited by smaller batteries, similar those made for compartment phones and laptops. In SNT’s warehouse, agleam reddish exigency h2o lines snake crossed the ceilings, a safeguard against calamity.

But seen different way, those aged batteries are an accidental for an adjacent greener automotive future. EVs are much eco-friendly than their gas-burning counterparts, but they inactive travel with biology costs. Batteries incorporate invaluable minerals similar cobalt and lithium, which are chiefly extracted and processed overseas, wherever they outgo section communities dearly successful labor abuses and captious resources like water and lend to planetary c emissions. Because of that, unchecked request for caller electrical cars volition “reduce greenhouse state emissions successful developed countries and municipality centers and sacrifice places” wherever the materials are mined, says Hanjiro Ambrose, an technologist astatine the University of California, Davis Institute of Transportation Studies.

Illustration: Allie Sullberg

In an perfect world, each of those lithium-ion batteries stacked successful the Oklahoma warehouse would beryllium reused and recycled, advertisement infinitum, to make the lithium-ion batteries of 10, 25, adjacent 50 years from now—with small caller worldly required. Experts telephone this a “circular economy.” To marque it work, recyclers are racing to travel up with an businesslike and planet-friendly mode to trim a utilized artillery to its astir invaluable parts and past remake them into thing new. Entrants see Redwood Materials, a Nevada steadfast led by erstwhile Tesla executives; Europe’s Northvolt; and Toronto-based Li-Cycle. Others program to compression each imaginable electron from a artillery earlier it's recycled by offering 2nd oregon 3rd uses aft it comes retired of a car.

In theory, according to research done successful the laboratory of Alissa Kendall, a prof of civilian and biology engineering astatine the University of California, Davis, recycled materials could proviso much than fractional of the cobalt, lithium, and nickel successful caller batteries by 2040, adjacent arsenic EVs get much popular. The emerging EV manufacture needs a astute end-of-life process for batteries, alongside wide charging stations, trained car technicians, and a fortified powerfulness grid. It’s indispensable infrastructure, cardinal to making our electrified aboriginal arsenic greenish arsenic possible. “We person to power these end-of-life batteries,” says Kendall. “It shouldn’t beryllium a fearfulness stream.”

One happening appears certain: The existent mode of dealing with cars past their premier won’t chopped it. Cars are typically globe-trotters; the mean conveyance whitethorn person 3 to 4 owners and transverse planetary borders successful its lifetime. When it yet dies, it falls into a globe-spanning web of auctioneers, dismantlers, and scrap yards that effort to dispose of cars arsenic profitably arsenic possible. “These vehicles spell to auction and anybody tin drawback them,” Kendall says. “That’s wherever the Wild West is.”

Today’s strategy mostly works due to the fact that scrap metallic has worth and there’s a steadfast marketplace for accepted car parts. Dismantlers—including those that alert nether the radar of regulators—make a good creation of wringing each penny from a dormant car, explains Andy Latham, CEO of Salvage Wire, an car recycling consultancy successful the UK. That includes the lead-acid batteries that commencement gas-powered cars. More than 95 percent of them are recycled contiguous due to the fact that consumers tin assertion deposits erstwhile they instrumentality the batteries, and they are comparatively elemental to dismantle. Lithium-ion artillery packs are, by contrast, dense machines with dozens of components and radically antithetic designs depending connected their manufacturer. “The voltages successful these batteries are lethal,” says Latham, who trains salvagers conscionable getting started with EVs. “People don’t cognize the risks involved.”

Extracting the invaluable materials from an EV artillery is hard and expensive. The recycling process typically involves shredding batteries, past breaking them down further with vigor oregon chemicals astatine dedicated facilities. That portion is comparatively simple. The harder portion is getting dormant batteries to those facilities from wherever they met their demise. About 40 percent of the wide cost of recycling, according to 1 caller study, is transportation. EV artillery packs are truthful monolithic they request to beryllium shipped by motortruck (not airplane) successful specially designed cases, often crossed immense distances, to scope centralized recycling facilities. Handling lithium-ion batteries is truthful demanding that dealerships person chosen to vessel an full 4,000-pound damaged conveyance to Oklahoma City, conscionable truthful SNT tin extract and repair oregon recycle the 1,000-pound artillery inside.

In all, the travel is truthful labor- and resource-intensive that it mostly exceeds the costs of digging up caller materials from the ground. Currently, the lone artillery worldly that tin beryllium recycled profitably is cobalt, due to the fact that it’s conscionable that uncommon and expensive. For the aforesaid reason, galore artillery makers anticipation to destruct it from their chemistries soon, threatening to marque the worth proposition for recyclers adjacent harder. “Recycling is not going to beryllium profitable for everybody. That’s phantasy economics,” says Leo Raudys, CEO of Call2Recycle, a nonprofit that handles recycling logistics for dormant batteries. Even cobalt-free batteries are toxic and a occurrence danger, though they inactive incorporate plentifulness of invaluable materials, similar lithium and nickel. But recycling them responsibly is simply little profitable.

In short, whoever ends up with a dormant artillery volition apt person to wage a recycler to instrumentality it disconnected their hands. Raudys compares it to the aboriginal epoch of handling physics waste, erstwhile producers and recyclers were caught connected their haunches. “You inactive saw a batch of conduit TVs extremity up successful ditches,” helium says.

There’s little hazard of that for EV artillery packs, Raudys says, successful portion due to the fact that they are truthful large and hard to hide. A landfill won’t instrumentality them knowingly due to the fact that of occurrence risk. A monolithic battalion dumped determination is easier to hint backmost to an owner, oregon astatine slightest to its manufacturer. That volition assistance support astir artillery packs connected the way to being recycled.

Hans Eric Melin, the laminitis of Circular Energy Storage, a consultancy that focuses connected artillery life-cycle management, agrees. Time volition lick aggregate problems. As much batteries die, the economies of standard volition thrust down costs. Another key, Melin says, is locating artillery makers and artillery recyclers person to each other. He notes that the astir highly developed artillery recycling manufacture is successful China, wherever 70 percent of lithium-ion batteries are made. In North America and Europe, there’s little manufacturing and little recycling. But immoderate automakers person set up in-house recycling programs to retrieve materials themselves, portion recyclers are besides reasoning astir artillery making. In September, Redwood Materials said it would statesman building artillery cathodes from recovered metals.

Still, others accidental immoderate batteries volition “leak” from these systems and not beryllium recycled immediately. Some electrical cars volition extremity up abroad, arsenic immoderate 40 percent of gas-powered vehicles presently do. It’s a communal destiny due to the fact that cars deemed unfit for US roads tin inactive beryllium shipped overseas and sold astatine a steep discount. Melin says a tiny fig of older EVs are already moving abroad. In his research, helium recovered it casual to way down older models of the all-electric Nissan Leaf successful Ukraine, wherever the institution did not merchantability them until this summer.

Sending utilized cars overseas is an important mode of making electrical vehicles accessible to poorer countries, Melin notes. But it raises the question of whether these places are prepared for harmless and environmentally dependable recycling erstwhile the vehicles die. “We person grounds from the e-waste commercialized that determination tin beryllium atrocious versions of recycling,” Kendall says, pointing to places similar India and Southeast Asia. “It’s a misery.”

Closer to home, different EV batteries whitethorn “leak” into shadowy corners of the home car industry, with players that don’t person the wealth oregon tendency to woody with waste. One effect is stockpiling batteries successful the hopes that recycling costs volition yet autumn oregon that the worth of the batteries volition rise. “Some of it is wishful thinking,” Kendall says. Sometimes, the batteries upwind up with enthusiastic but not ever safety-minded DIYers. That tin beryllium useful, due to the fact that those DIYers are apt to compression much electrons retired of utilized batteries by repurposing them for caller applications, similar at-home vigor storage. But immoderate artillery packs are breached down into idiosyncratic cells oregon modules for repurposing, which means they’re much apt to spell missing.

Government volition apt get involved, too, arsenic it did with the deposit strategy for lead-acid batteries. Last year, the European Union proposed regulations that would necessitate artillery and car manufacturers to grip recycling batteries, careless of who owns them astatine the extremity of their lives. “The dismantler tin crook astir and say, ‘I don't privation this happening successful my yard. Here, instrumentality it away, Honda oregon Tesla oregon Toyota,’” explains Latham of Salvage Wire. New standards successful the EU would besides dictate however overmuch of the precious metals wrong of caller batteries volition request to beryllium recycled from past devices, alternatively than virgin material.

Regulating the artillery manufacture requires a cautious balance, explains Melin. Strict rules aimed astatine maximizing the greenness of EVs mightiness dilatory the adoption of electrical cars and pb to burning much fossil fuels—a acold worse destiny for the planet. A peculiar interest for automakers is simply a request with a precocious threshold of recycled materials to beryllium included successful caller batteries; that could beryllium hard to achieve, particularly successful the adjacent term, and could summation artillery costs.

In the US, California’s Environmental Protection Agency has convened an advisory committee to see imaginable rules for artillery recycling. In caller meetings, automotive manufacture lobbyists person argued that whoever takes the artillery retired of a car astatine the extremity of its beingness should beryllium liable for ensuring that it makes it to a recycler, perchance aided by incentives. Automakers would service arsenic a backstop for the batteries that autumn done the cracks.

In Oklahoma City, the batteries successful the SNT warehouse mostly came from cars that are inactive nether warranty, which means the automakers are liable for them. Tyler Helps, the company’s caput of concern development, says automakers are paying SNT to support their aged batteries due to the fact that they don’t cognize what the utilized artillery marketplace is going to look similar and whether the materials wrong the artillery mightiness beryllium much invaluable successful the future. “So alternatively of the automakers saying, ‘I'm going to spell and dispose of those materials,’ they say, ‘I’m conscionable going to clasp onto it,’” helium says.

Sitting successful a league country conscionable down the hallway from the towers of batteries, Spiers himself expresses optimism. The past tenant of this warehouse was a institution that constructed parts for lipid pipelines, helium points out. Now it’s owned by a institution helping automakers guarantee their electrical cars are arsenic greenish arsenic they tin be. They’re inactive figuring retired the program for galore of the batteries successful this warehouse, but Spiers believes that successful the end, they’ll beryllium viewed arsenic an opportunity, not waste. “​​If you tin physique an economical exemplary that works arsenic a carrot, past it makes consciousness for the full manufacture to enactment toward this goal,” helium says. “I deliberation that is simply a overmuch bigger motivator than regulation.” He's motivated to get this right. There are, aft all, large things astatine involvement here—like the planet.


More Great WIRED Stories