Plea Deal Rejected for Couple Accused of Selling Nuclear Submarine Secrets

1 month ago 38

A federal justice connected Aug. 16 rejected a plea woody for a U.S. Navy nuclear technologist and his woman who are accused of attempting to merchantability U.S. submarine secrets to a overseas government.

Jonathan, 42, and Diana Toebbe, 45, from Annapolis, Maryland were arrested by the FBI and the Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS) in October 2021 during a drawstring cognition and charged with one number of “conspiracy to pass restricted data” and 2 counts of the “communication of restricted data.”

Prosecutors alleged that the mates had sold “restricted data” for astir a twelvemonth to an idiosyncratic they believed was a typical of a overseas government. The information acrophobic the design of nuclear-powered warships.

However, the idiosyncratic they were attempting to merchantability the accusation to was really an undercover FBI agent.

The mates pleaded blameworthy successful February successful national tribunal successful Martinsburg, West Virginia, to 1 number each of conspiracy to pass restricted information arsenic portion of plea deals that saw 2 counts of connection of restricted information dropped.

Under the plea agreement, Diana Toebbe would serve no much than 3 years successful national situation portion Jonathan Toebbe would spend between astir 12 years and 17 years down bars.

However, connected Tuesday, U.S. District Court Judge Gina Groh of the Northern District of West Virginia rejected those plea deals, stating that they were “not successful the champion interest” of the country.

The justice said the couples’ actions were done “for selfish and greedy reasons” but could person caused large harm to the Navy and others.

“Counsel, it’s not successful the champion involvement of this assemblage or, successful fact, this state to judge these plea agreements,” Groh said. “Therefore, I’m rejecting them. I don’t find immoderate justifiable reasons for accepting either 1 of these plea agreements.”

As a effect of Groh’s decision, the Toebbe’s separately withdrew their guilty pleas and Groh acceptable a caller proceedings day for Jan. 17.

Unrestricted Access to Nuclear Data

Jonathan Toebbe, a atomic Navy technologist who was assigned to the Naval Nuclear Propulsion Program, besides known arsenic Naval Reactors, held an progressive nationalist information clearance done the U.S. Department of Defense, meaning helium was capable to entree restricted information regarding reactors for nuclear-powered warships.

According to prosecutors, the FBI became progressive successful the couple’s strategy aft an agent obtained a package intended for a overseas entity that contained a illustration of restricted information on with instructions connected however to found a mode to acquisition further restricted data.

Prosecutors said the bundle contained U.S. Navy documents, a missive with instructions, and an SD paper containing circumstantial instructions connected however the recipient should pass with the Toebbes via an encrypted connection platform.

“I apologize for this mediocre translation into your language. Please guardant this missive to your subject quality agency,” the missive with instructions stated, according to prosecutors. “I judge this accusation volition beryllium of large worth to your nation,” it added.

During the sting operation, email correspondence betwixt the mates and the undercover FBI cause continued for respective months earlier the Toebbes struck a woody with the cause to sell the restricted information for thousands of dollars successful cryptocurrency.

Prosecutors said the mates would conceal an SD paper containing restricted information relating to submarine atomic reactors wrong a peanut food sandwich oregon a chewing gum bundle and permission it astatine an arranged drop-off determination for undercover agents.

Jonathan Toebbe’s lawyer, Nicholas J. Compton, told the justice connected Tuesday that the 12 to 17 years scope down bars was “not a slap connected the wrist” and was a  significant punishment,” The Washington Post reported.

Diana Toebbe’s attorney, Barry P. Beck, said a shorter word was needed for his lawsuit because “her hubby had an ill-conceived thought to marque money, and she agreed to spell on with it.”

Ultimately though, justice Groh disagreed. The mates are expected to scope caller plea agreements with the authorities earlier the adjacent proceedings date.

Katabella Roberts


Katabella Roberts is simply a quality writer for The Epoch Times, focusing chiefly connected the United States, world, and concern news.