The Renewable Energy ‘Paradox’: A More Costly Way Forward

3 months ago 21

A California-based leading eco-modernist has disputed the wide assertion that renewables are a inexpensive and cleanable vigor source, arguing that it’s the opposite.

Michael Shellenberger, laminitis of Environmental Progress, said 1 of the “most misleading ways that renewable salespeople merchantability their technology” is they assertion the energy produced by upwind and star is cheaper.  

However, the paradox astir renewable vigor is erstwhile deployed astatine scale, they really marque energy accumulation much expensive, Shellenberger told CPAC Australia successful Sydney connected Oct. 1. 

“There are fundamentally 2 reasons,” helium said, “It requires much machines, much backup powerfulness generators, much transmission systems, and much radical to negociate the chaos of an electrical grid with a ample magnitude of unreliable weather-dependent energy.”  

Shellenberger pointed to a prediction by German economist Leon Hirth that the economical worth of upwind and star declines importantly arsenic they instrumentality up a larger proportionality of the energy grid.  

In a insubstantial for Energy Policy successful 2013, Hirth estimated that erstwhile upwind turbine powerfulness procreation comprises 30 percent of the grid, its worth declines by 40 percent; portion star power’s worth declines by 50 percent erstwhile it reaches 15 percent.  

“The crushed is casual to understand,” Shellenberger noted, “Solar and upwind nutrient excessively overmuch vigor erstwhile you don’t request them and not capable vigor erstwhile you do, and some of those enforce costs connected the electrical grid.”  

Epoch Times Photo Steam rises from cooling towers of the Neurath coal-fired powerfulness works arsenic upwind turbines rotation implicit a tract of rapeseed connected May 05, 2022 adjacent Bedburg, Germany. (Photo by Andreas Rentz/Getty Images)

He said the perfect concern was for the energy proviso to support up with request astatine “all times.”

“Every clip you instrumentality energy disconnected the grid and enactment it backmost on, you’re paying vigor penalties, which summation the outgo of that vigor determination betwixt 20 to 40 percent.”

Shellenberger said this was the lawsuit whether it was utilizing energy to pump h2o uphill to run hydroelectric dams oregon siphoning excess energy proviso into lithium batteries. He noted that it would outgo the United States three-quarters of a trillion dollars to make capable retention to backmost up the full country’s energy grid for conscionable 4 hours.  

“We don’t request to backup the grid for 4 hours, we request to backmost it up if you’re relying connected star and upwind for weeks oregon months due to the fact that determination are periods of clip wherever there’s nary sunlight, nary wind, including often astatine night,” helium said.  

What About the Waste?  

The comments from the environmentalist travel arsenic Western countries ramp up their efforts to decarbonise to determination towards nett zero by 2050, with renewables believed to beryllium the solution arsenic they nutrient neither greenhouse gases nor polluting emissions.

But Shellenberger, writer of “Apocalypse Never: Why Environmental Alarmism Hurts Us All” and “San Fransicko: Why Progressives Ruin Cities,” argued that renewables were much environmentally damaging than fossil fuels and atomic energy. 

Epoch Times Photo A pistillate walks done the star pannels of a photovoltaic powerfulness works installed by Generale du Soleil (GDS) and operated by Energ’iV SEML successful a erstwhile landfill of waste, connected December 8, 2020 successful Guignen, occidental France. (Photo by Loic Venance/AFP via Getty Images)

Renewables nutrient 300 times much discarded than atomic plants do, portion each star sheet removed from a rooftop was categorised arsenic hazardous waste, the environmentalist noted.  

“The occupation is that renewables really degrade the earthy environment,” helium said. 

Shellenberger besides said the propulsion for much renewable powerfulness sources similar upwind and star would effect successful Western countries moving “in the other absorption towards a ‘higher worldly intensity’ nine than we person nether fossil fuels and nuclear.” 

According to a study from the International Energy Agency, earthy state and ember lone necessitate a tiny fraction of mining to enactment their operations compared to what is needed for offshore upwind and solar.  

“We usage astir 10 percent of the materials successful the satellite contiguous for vigor production, if we determination towards 100 percent renewables that would emergence to betwixt 40 and 50 percent, and that’s going to beryllium inflationary.” 

He further said that “as a effect of the warfare connected earthy gas, and this obsession with renewables, the world’s really going to pain much ember successful 2022 than it ever has before.”

“As a effect of the underinvestment successful earthy gas, the satellite has been reverting to coal.” 

Nina Nguyen


Nina Nguyen is simply a newsman based successful Sydney. She covers Australian quality with a absorption connected social, cultural, and individuality issues. She is fluent successful Vietnamese. Contact her astatine [email protected]