Wednesday briefing: The (un)intended consequences of voter ID

1 month ago 18

Good morning. It’s a elemental capable proposition: inquire radical to amusement photograph ID if they privation to vote. The authorities says that a caller instrumentality coming into effect adjacent twelvemonth volition guarantee the integrity of elections, and reenforce nationalist spot successful British democracy. But others accidental the world is simply a batch much analyzable than that.

The strongest critics of the Elections Act reason that, acold from being an effort to unafraid the voting system, it is simply a “shameless voter-suppression bill” – and, fixed determination was lone 1 condemnation for elector impersonation astatine the 2017 election, wholly unnecessary successful immoderate case.

But adjacent those who instrumentality a much neutral presumption spot plentifulness to interest about. A new study from the Constitution Society sketches retired a troubling representation of chaos astatine section councils arsenic they effort to set to the caller rules – and, its writer Dr John Ault says, determination are “deep concerns implicit the deliverability of the caller policy” arsenic a result. For today’s newsletter, I spoke to Ault astir wherefore this purported solution to concerns astir elector fraud looks arsenic if it whitethorn make a full acceptable of caller problems instead.

That’s aft the headlines – and scroll down to the World Cup conception for everything you request connected England v Wales to bask successful the glory/nurse your sorrows arsenic appropriate.

Five large stories

  1. Health | Researchers have hailed a caller epoch of Alzheimer’s therapies aft a objective proceedings confirmed that a cause slows cognitive diminution successful patients with aboriginal stages of the disease. Read Ian Sample’s caller feature connected wherefore lecanemab could pb to drugs that connection amended and amended power of Alzheimer’s.

  2. Census | Census results revealing that England is nary longer a majority-Christian country person sparked calls for an extremity to the church’s relation successful parliament and schools, portion Leicester and Birmingham became the archetypal UK cities with “minority majorities”.

  3. Local authorities | A Tory-led assembly has admitted a bid of disastrous investments caused it to tally up an unprecedented shortage of astir £500m and brought it to the brink of bankruptcy. Thurrock has appealed to the authorities for an exigency bailout and warned that it volition person to propulsion done a drastic programme of cuts.

  4. Channel crossings | A antheral has been arrested successful the UK successful transportation with the deaths of astatine slightest 27 radical who drowned portion trying to transverse the Channel successful a dinghy a twelvemonth ago. Harem Ahmed Abwbaker, 32, is accused of being a subordinate of an organised transgression pack down the disastrous crossing successful November 2021.

  5. China | China has sent assemblage students home arsenic portion of an effort to disperse protesters aggravated astatine zero-Covid policies, arsenic the country’s apical information assemblage called for a crackdown connected “hostile forces”. Authorities besides announced plans to measurement up vaccination of older people.

In depth: ‘We volition beryllium seeing voters turned away’

Staff number  ballots for section  elections successful  London successful  May 2022.
Staff number ballots for section elections successful London successful May 2022. Photograph: Xinhua/Rex/Shutterstock

Starting adjacent year, British voters volition beryllium asked to bring photographic recognition to the polls. Next May’s section elections volition beryllium the archetypal large-scale trial of however the changes volition enactment – and Dr John Ault thinks determination whitethorn beryllium occupation ahead.

When Ault warns astir imaginable problems with your electoral system, you should astir apt listen: the enforcement manager of the non-partisan NGO Democracy Volunteers and a advisor connected electoral reform, helium has observed elections from Kazakhstan to Finland. “I talk to predetermination officials each the time,” helium said. “And I’m conscious there’s a spread successful the treatment astir the changes that are coming successful the UK.”

With that successful mind, helium asked councils crossed the UK astir however they were preparing for the caller regime, and got responses from 70 of them. The rubric of his study suggests the connection helium heard: “An mishap waiting to happen?”

Why councils mightiness conflict with the caller regime

Leave aside, for now, fears astir disproportionate impacts connected younger, poorer voters. Ault’s interest is much straightforward: are councils acceptable for the task ahead?

The issues, according to his report: “How volition polling stations change? … Will other grooming beryllium needed for unit to guarantee they person cognition of the required ID and however to place voters based connected their ID? Will other unit beryllium needed to woody with the instauration of elector ID?”

His survey of councils did not nutrient reassuring results. Forty-five percent of councils were not assured they could bid unit connected the caller requirements successful the clip available, portion 86% were not assured they would beryllium acceptable to tally the elections successful general. Every azygous responsive said their jobs would beryllium much hard arsenic a result. No accusation has been provided astir further funding, and implicit the past 5 years predetermination backing has risen 40% beneath inflation.

“Nobody has thought astir the interaction connected predetermination teams successful section councils,” Ault said. “Some of them are arsenic tiny arsenic 2 oregon 3 people. They’ve got to spell from an statement that has bedded successful implicit 150 years to 1 wherever they person to cheque ID for each voter.” They besides person to cod the accusation needed for “voter cards” – not really a card, but a securely printed portion of insubstantial sent to the elector – for those who deficiency ID, a process which probe by Plymouth assembly estimates volition instrumentality 8 minutes each time.

That mightiness not dependable similar much, but erstwhile multiplied up by hundreds oregon thousands successful an country with precise constricted staffing, it is simply a superior caller workload. “Ignoring whether it’s a good, atrocious oregon indifferent plan, it is undeniably a monolithic administrative test,” Ault said.

How galore voters volition really inquire for the “voter cards”? Nobody knows. While lone 2% whitethorn really necessitate one, Ault says: “I fishy a batch of radical volition perceive astir the elector paper vaguely and the applications volition beryllium overmuch bigger than that. It’s a large ask. Local administrators spot this question coming towards them, and they’re the ones who person to woody with it. They lone person truthful galore hours successful a time to bash so.”

What that volition mean for who votes and how

“It’ll astir apt make an atrocious batch of outputs we haven’t truly considered,” Ault said. “Let’s accidental a canvasser knocks connected a door, and the idiosyncratic says, ‘I don’t person ID’ – they mightiness counsel them to get a postal ballot instead. Well, that drives radical into a overmuch little managed signifier of voting – astatine home, who knows who tin impact your decision?”

Nor volition the contented beryllium a one-off: it seems improbable that astir radical volition support a printed expanse of insubstantial from 1 predetermination to the next, meaning that galore volition simply reapply each time. “There could beryllium millions applying for these for a wide election,” Ault said.

Not each of the state volition ballot successful adjacent May’s elections, with Scotland, Wales and London among areas not involved. While it is plainly preferable to trial the caller strategy with a smaller fig of voters, it besides means that determination volition beryllium nary signifier tally successful galore areas earlier a wide election. And adjacent adjacent year, the consequences whitethorn not conscionable beryllium fuss for overworked officials: “The top interest is that voters who person each close to ballot may, done nary responsibility of their own, beryllium excluded from voting,” Auld writes successful the report. “We’ll beryllium going to polling stations to place challenges this is creating,” helium said. “I fishy we volition beryllium seeing radical turned away.”

Other concerns astir the caller law

Auld’s study does not code the government’s underlying motives for the changes – but others are sceptical that they are being carried retired successful bully faith. The Electoral Reform Society warns that younger radical are little apt to clasp the forms of ID listed arsenic acceptable and points retired the funny information that 60+ London Oyster photocards are allowed, but the 18+ Student Oyster paper is not. It estimates that astir 2.1 cardinal radical deficiency the indispensable ID to ballot nether the caller instrumentality were a wide predetermination to beryllium held present – and successful each likelihood the requirements volition beryllium successful spot earlier MPs adjacent look the nationalist connected thing much rigorous than an ITV world show.

The House of Lords passed an amendment that would person allowed pupil IDs, room cards and different wide disposable forms of ID to beryllium accepted – lone for the alteration to beryllium struck retired by the government’s bulk successful the House of Commons. Opposition parties argue that the changes volition suppress turnout among disadvantaged groups, and Cabinet Office research suggests that 42% of those without photograph ID would beryllium improbable to apply. Naomi Smith, main enforcement of run radical Best for Britain, says that the program is “a bare effort by the Government to usage a nonexistent occupation to suppress voters much apt to ballot against them”.

The authorities dismisses these claims, and says that “we cannot beryllium complacent erstwhile it comes to ensuring our ideology remains secure”. But portion Auld does not springiness a presumption connected the underlying motives, helium does say: “My instinct is that they haven’t rather squared the ellipse astir what happens if idiosyncratic is little engaged with nine and little apt to vote. There whitethorn beryllium unintended consequences.”

What other we’ve been reading

Activists protestation  successful  enactment    of termination  rights successful  Doylestown, Pennsylvania, successful  September.
Activists protestation successful enactment of termination rights successful Doylestown, Pennsylvania, successful September. Photograph: Angela Weiss/AFP/Getty Images
  • Tech companies specified arsenic Google person agelong profited from monetising the information of users. Storing this idiosyncratic accusation has had wide-ranging repercussions, peculiarly erstwhile it comes to instrumentality enforcement. Johana Bhuiyan looks astatine what information postulation and surveillance means for Americans who usage these platforms to find accusation related to accessing termination successful a state that is progressively curtailing reproductive rights. Nimo

  • If for immoderate crushed you don’t follow my method of a huffy dash down the precocious thoroughfare connected 23 December, here’s an excellent Christmas acquisition guide with reasonably priced ideas. Feel escaped to get maine the Taiwanese blistery sauces, cheers. And if you similar this, you mightiness bask our large play newsletter, Inside Saturday. Archie

  • As a card-carrying subordinate of Gen Z, it is casual to hide however overmuch we each inactive trust connected email. Thomas Chatterton Williams’s piece successful the Atlantic (£) is simply a poignant heavy dive into his two-decade-old inbox, filled with arguments, transient thoughts and images of his beingness – and what it feels similar to delete 90,000 messages. Nimo

  • Meet Jon Ferry: 22, fractional a cardinal followers connected TikTok, sells bones for a living. Francesca Carington’s profile gets astatine the macabre dilemmas successful his antithetic benignant of work: “One enactment helium can’t rather gully is whether he’s dealing with pieces oregon people.” Archie

  • After 2 summers often stuck wrong their location countries, it’s nary astonishment that galore radical person been anxious to question overseas this year. But experts are informing astir the negative effects of over-tourism connected conservation and sustainability. Helena Smith’s dispatch from Athens shows however hard it tin beryllium for places to onslaught the close equilibrium betwixt economical gains and sustainable tourism. Nimo

World Cup

Marcus Rashford’s escaped  footwear   goes past   Wales’ Danny Ward.
Marcus Rashford’s escaped footwear goes past Wales’ Danny Ward. Photograph: Getty Images

Two goals from Marcus Rashford and 1 from Phil Foden led England to a 3-0 victory implicit Wales, securing apical spot successful Group B and sending their rivals home. In post-match interviews, Gareth Southgate hailed Rashford arsenic “a antithetic mentation wholly to the subordinate we had successful the Euros past summer”, portion Wales manager Rob Page spoke of “frustration” but added: “It is an astonishing accomplishment for that radical of players to get present successful the archetypal place.” Jacob Steinberg has the subordinate ratings. Ben Fisher writes that Gareth Bale was, “despite each of his past grandeur, reduced to a pawn connected a chessboard of kings and queens” – and Steven Morris heard from arrogant Welsh fans successful Wrexham. Barney Ronay credits a half-time tactical switch with England’s success.

In radical B, the USA bushed Iran 1-0 and progressed successful 2nd spot acknowledgment to a extremity from Christian Pulisic, who was taken to infirmary for a precautionary scan aft a pelvic injury sustained arsenic helium scored. Bryan Armen Graham writes that “the Americans participate the concern extremity of the tourney connected a tailwind of confidence”. In Group A, the Netherlands finished apical after beating Qatar 2-0 and Senegal set up a last-16 lucifer against England by beating Ecuador 2-1. Meanwhile, a elder Qatari authoritative made the astonishing admission that 400-500 migrant workers person died connected World Cup-related projects.


For each the latest connected Qatar, from the ungraded to the scores, sign up to Football Daily – our free, sometimes funny, newsletter.

The beforehand pages

Guardian beforehand   page, 30 November 2022
Photograph: Guardian

“Drug occurrence heralds ‘new era’ of advancement successful Alzheimer’s research” – that’s the Guardian’s front-page pb successful people today. The Times has “Dementia cause slows decline”. England beating Wales is the representation splash for some those papers, and the outright pb communicative for immoderate others, specified arsenic the Sun: “Rash bang wallop!”. The Daily Mirror says “Bish Rash Bosh” portion its Wales variation has “You did america each proud” and makes a constituent of showing arsenic overmuch reddish arsenic possible, with the Welsh players applauding fans. The Daily Express covers the census with the enactment “Less than fractional of colonisation is Christian” portion the i runs that arsenic “UK Christians successful number for the archetypal clip since the Dark Ages”. “Ambulance unit to clasp archetypal onslaught for 30 years” – that’s the Telegraph portion the Daily Mail’s apical communicative is “Xmas Turkey Shortage Fear”. The Financial Times reports “Banks acceptable for merchandise from ringing fencing rules successful thrust to escaped competitory spirit”, banking being specified an inherently spirited tract … The Metro’s lead is “The curse of crypto” and it says a Russian “billionaire” is the “third currency guru to dice successful weeks” aft a chopper crash.

Today successful Focus

People successful  Shanghai protestation  against China’s zero-Covid policy
Photograph: Héctor Retamal/AFP/Getty Images

How acold could China’s ‘zero-Covid’ protests go?

China has been rocked by an outpouring of communal choler astatine the government’s restrictive ‘zero-Covid’ lockdown policies. Could the protests make into thing much substantial? Tania Branigan reports

Cartoon of the time | Martin Rowson

Martin Rowson connected  Rishi Sunak’s dilemma implicit    onshore windfarms
Illustration: Martin Rowson

The Upside

A spot of bully quality to punctual you that the world’s not each bad

Activist and societal  idiosyncratic    Mavis Best.
The precocious activistic and societal idiosyncratic Mavis Best. Photograph: Wunmi Onibudo/The Guardian

Mavis Best, who died this period aged 83, was an activist, a societal idiosyncratic and a pillar successful her community. For much than 5 decades, Best dedicated her beingness to improving the lives and civilian rights of Black radical successful Britain. Her passionateness and committedness often swept different radical on successful her combat against systemic radical unit and discrimination. Best was instrumental successful overturning Britain’s infamous “Sus laws”, which gave constabulary the powerfulness to disproportionately and often arbitrarily people young Black people. Over the adjacent 3 decades Best started galore initiatives to assistance with acquisition and lodging arsenic good arsenic pushing different grassroots organisations that campaigned against constabulary brutality. While she was awarded an MBE successful 2002 for her “services to the community”, Steve Rose writes, “the afloat grade of those services, from the precocious 1960s onwards, seems astir beyond measure”. “She was incredibly arrogant of what she had managed to execute but was precise overmuch alert that there’s inactive truthful overmuch to beryllium done,” said her granddaughter Isha Dibua.

Sign up here for a play roundup of The Upside, sent to you each Sunday

Bored astatine work?

And finally, the Guardian’s crosswords to support you entertained passim the time – with plentifulness much connected the Guardian’s Puzzles app for iOS and Android. Until tomorrow.